Why a High Price Usually Sells for Less
It feels safe to start high and come down, but the market doesn't reward it.
- The first two weeks matter most. A new listing goes to every buyer with a matching saved search and every agent's client alerts on day one. Homes priced in line with recent sold comparables draw the most showings in that window and sell closest to asking. Price above it and the buyers who would have paid your real value never open the listing.
- Buyers search in bands. A home worth $740,000 listed at $775,000 drops out of every search capped at $750,000, and the buyers who do see it compare it with better homes at $775,000.
- Days on market become the story. Once a listing has sat, buyers and agents assume something is wrong and offer below where you'd have sold at the start. Price reductions tend to chase the market down rather than catch it.
Start With What Sold, Not What's Listed
Asking prices tell you what other sellers hope for. Sold prices tell you what buyers paid. Look at homes like yours that sold in your community in the last 90 days and adjust for size, condition and upgrades.
- What have similar homes near me sold for?
- Which homes are most comparable to mine, and what did they sell for?
Sign in to see sold prices. Your Homeowner Dashboard also shows an Estimated Value for your home as a low-to-high range with a confidence percentage, and you can correct the details it's based on with Edit Details. Ask Bōdie how it was calculated to see the comparables behind it. See How does Bōde estimate what my home is worth?
When a Higher Price Can Work
- Few true comparables. A home with an unusual lot, a legal suite or a rare location may have no recent match. Price from the nearest comparables and explain the difference in your description.
- A rising market. If the last three comparable sales each went for more than the one before, pricing at the top of the range is pricing to the trend rather than above it.
- No deadline. If you can wait, you can test a higher price, but set yourself a review date before you list.
If You Want to Test the Market
Decide in advance what will tell you the price is wrong: no showing requests in the first two weeks, or showings without an offer in the first four. When you reach that point, make one meaningful reduction rather than several small ones. Submit the change from My Listings and the Bōde team syncs it to the MLS® and Realtor.ca. See How do I edit my listing?
Ask Bōdie: Is my asking price in line with what similar homes have sold for recently?